Anita Shackelford
Contact me  
  • Home
  • Digitized Patterns
  • Short Arm Patterns
  • Made by Hand - Books, Templates, Needles
  • Needles
  • For sale
  • Quilt Rescue
  • Statler Tutorials
  • Red and Green Quilts
  • Kids at Work
  • About Anita
  • Contact
  • What's New
  • Store

Judging Computerized Quilting

6/11/2021

4 Comments

 
Picture

Many longarm machines, some domestic machines, give quilters the option of quilting with a stitch regulator, if they so desire. “Wonderful, but how can we compare that to real quilting?” Some machines can also stitch a completely computer-controlled pattern. “Amazing, but is that fair?” These questions can be heard at almost every quilt show these days. As a quilter and a judge, I can easily put myself on both sides of this question.
 
I’ve been quilting by hand for more than fifty years. For me, it’s relaxing and the most beautiful work I can ever think of doing. I’ve been quilting with my sewing machine for about thirty-five years. It’s fast work, sturdy enough for grandchildren and it helps me feel I might actually be able to use up some of my stash. Over the past fifteen years, I’ve been quilting on a Gammill longarm with a Statler Stitcher. This machine seems to me to be a miracle of modern quilting.
 
Working first on the computer, I can open a quilting design and make it any size I want, limited only by the working space between the rollers. I can set a pattern to fill a block of any dimension, to follow a vertical line, a horizontal line, or rotate it to any angle or any position. The computer will repeat patterns to fill a calculated space, so that borders or pantographs come out even. I can choose from thousands of available designs or use a CAD program to create my own. And yes, it does have a stitch regulator for free-motion quilting, when I choose to work that way.
 
And so, the questions come, “Is it fair to have computer guided quilting in the same category or the same show as other quilts?” This sounds like the same argument we have answered before about hand quilting vs. machine quilting, domestic machine vs. longarm, stitch regulated or not. Instead of fair or not, the question in a judged competition should be “Is it well done or not?”
 
Computerized machines are amazing, but can they do the quilting all by themselves? I have invited several people to come and try my machine. If I say, as we stand in front of it, “Go ahead and quilt whatever you like” of course they say they don’t know how. So then, why would anyone think that using a machine of any kind will guarantee perfect results? Knowledge, practice, and experience are necessary to help every quilter improve his or her skills no matter what technique or style of quilting. And when a quilter reaches that point of perfection, that’s when the ribbons are awarded.
 
It seems surprising that I would find myself in the position of defending a computerized longarm quilting machine, when it is as far away from my traditional hand quilting roots as anything could be. But, as judges, we have to separate ourselves from our own style of work and look for the “best of the best” regardless of how it was done.
 
When judges evaluate any type of quilting, what do they look for? Even stitches, balanced tension, clean starts and stops, good design, no distortion in the quilt top or back, straight lines and/or smooth curves would be on the list. Those things can be done well with computerized quilting, or they can still be a problem. It depends on the skill and knowledge of the quilter. I am happy to see that most quiltmakers and quilt show organizers have accepted computerized quilting just as they have all other forms of work. And judges will do their job, as always, looking beyond “how” the quilt was made and concentrating on “how well” the work was done.
4 Comments
Joyce Greer link
6/11/2021 08:11:39 am

Anita, I am going to share this with my longarm group and my guild. Oh yes, also on my blog. Thank you .

Reply
Jackie Van Houten
6/11/2021 10:16:05 am

Well said. I’ve seen computerized quilts with all kinds of flaws and also the show quilts. The general public thinks you just push a button and get perfection. I’m glad that judges know the difference.

Reply
Jami Goto
6/11/2021 10:42:01 am

I too come from a hand quilting background and what you’ve said is spot on. I agree that views on computerized quilting have come a long way, but I still find that some judges just can’t accept it. I think one finds that in all forms of judging when it comes to a “new” way of doing things. We are still artists no matter how we got there. I value your expertise and learned so much from you and Joan at a retreat I attended in the wine country a few years back, and wouldn’t be the artist that I am today without what I learned from you and other talented computerized longarmers.

If I may, I will be sharing your words of wisdom.

Reply
PJJ Informatika link
2/26/2025 01:28:21 am

How do stitch regulators and computer-controlled patterns compare to traditional quilting?

Regard <a href="https://bolif.telkomuniversity.ac.id/registrasi-semester-ganjil-tahun-akademik-2020-2021/">PJJ Informatika</a>

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Anita has a long background rooted in traditional handwork and quiltmaking, which she still enjoys.

    Often, these days, you'll find her digitizing patterns for the Statler Stitcher and other computerized longarm quilting machines. 
     
    Her summer days are spent in the garden and she loves finding new ways to prepare good veggie-based meals.


    She's always in search of a way to balance all of those activities and find time to share with others who are passionate about the same things.

    This page is a sneak peek into what's happening in her world right now.

    Archives

    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020

    Categories

    All
    Binding
    Christmas
    Country Living
    Handmade
    Kitchen Garden
    Landscape
    Meatless Monday
    Pottery
    Quilting
    Quilt Rescue

    RSS Feed